Gamefly Accuses Postal Service of "Discrimination"

By  |  Friday, April 24, 2009 at 10:43 am

gamefly_logoVideo games tend to be frowned upon as second-class media, but the US Postal Service is taking that stance literally, according to a complaint by Gamefly, which rents video games through the mail.

In a 17-page complaint filed with the Postal Regulatory Commission (via Ars Technica), GameFly says that 1 percent to 2 percent of its games are breaking in transit. Even more interesting is Gamefly’s allegation that the postal service gives “preferential treatment” to Netflix and Blockbuster.

Gamefly takes issue with the use of an automated sorting system that has a tendency to damage discs. While the postal service manually sorts out “a large percentage” of DVDs from Blockbuster and Netflix, it refuses to do the same for Gamefly under equal terms.

Adding insult to injury, the postal service boasted in a July 2008 press release that it was helping Gamefly prosper when the company opened a new shipping center. “GameFly may be a relatively new company, but it’s using an old idea— getting USPS to help it grow,” the statement said.

Gamefly filed the complaint on four counts, among them “Unlawful Discrimination Among DVD Mailers” and “Unlawful Discrimination Among Flats Mailers.” The company says it wants the same terms and prices that Netflix and Blockbuster are getting and may seek “additional forms of relief as the evidentiary record justifies.”

With 590,000 discs going out per month, Gamefly is shelling out almost $300,000 per month to replace broken discs if you assume a cost of $50 per game. That hurts enough on its own, but as Gamefly points out, Blockbuster is getting into mail-order game rentals now, allegedly without the same shipping headaches.

This explains why I’ve received a few different varieties of mailers during my two years of membership with Gamefly. I used to get cardboard inserts in the mail, but that practice was abandoned last year at one point abandoned, and has since continued again. Apparently, it was too expensive because of the weight increase, and it didn’t the extra cost still doesn’t stop all the discs from breaking.


Read more: 

4 Comments For This Post

  1. DaveZatz Says:

    Hm, interesting. Especially since my all of my Gamefly discs have come enclosed in a cardboard sleeve, unlike my Netflix discs. I’ve had zero broken GF games, several broken Netflix DVDs. Although, I suspect it was the mail carrier at my last address who was responsible. (And I also receive a higher quantity of DVDs than games.)

  2. Jared Newman Says:

    Dave, you’re absolutely right. I’ve got a couple of those sleeves sitting around right now. I’m thinking of last year when I suddenly stopped receiving them for a while. At some point they started showing up again, not sure when.

    Post updated to provide the appropriate level of public shaming.

  3. DaveZatz Says:

    I rotate games infrequently. So I have no idea if they stopped or took a hiatus – wasn’t attempting to shame you! 🙂 The only thing I can think of that would break them is some postal carrier forcing it into a too-small mailbox or an industrial shredder at postal facilities.

  4. Alex Says:

    This doesn’t surprise me. I have Netflix and gamefly. Both companies have shipping centers in Pittsburgh. More often than not, I can send games and DVDs back on the same day, they arrive at the same time and the next items on my queues are sent around the same time. However, my Netflix will come in while my games end up a day late.