The Zune HD is Only HD to a Point

By  |  Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 1:45 pm

The term “HD” is often more about marketing than it is about accurately describing a product’s capabilities. Microsoft’s upcoming Zune HD is the latest example of that trend. The Zune HD looks like it will delivera compelling evolution over the previous-generation Zunes, with features including a touch-screen interface and a widescreen 480-by-272 OLED display. But while it will also offer HD video output and HD radio reception, it will fall short in delivering genuine HD playback.

The Zune’s OLED display is a 480-by-272 widescreen, which doesn’t meet anybody’s definition of HD. It’s only when you use a premium HDMI A/V docking station to output video to an HDTV that you get high definition–720p, to be exact.

That’s as far as its HD support goes. High definition video requires a minimum of 720-pixel resolution, and high definition audio is 24-bit; the Zune HD’s built-in playback falls short on both counts. A Microsoft spokesperson said that the company does not have any details to share regarding audio tracks or specific video files.

Microsoft is not alone in its marketing practices. “My daughter’s Sony VAIO has a sticker that says ‘Full HD’ [which suggests 1080p]. But the screen resolution is 1280 x 800. The “Full HD” comes from connecting the computer by HDMI to a monitor or TV,” said Joe Wilcox, an independent technology analyst.

While OLED screens deliver sharp colors and deep blacks–one benedit of HD–those advantages are almost entirely lost on a small screen with low resolution. And video marketplaces sometimes decrease the size of downloads by limiting black levels and other palette-related settings, said Matt Hargett, a noted technology author.

Microsoft could compensate for the Zune’s lack of HD video playback with 24-bit audio, Hargett said. Microsoft obtained the rights to the HDCD format in 2000. “Having 24-bit audio would be a great step forward.”

CDs introduced 16-bit lossless audio almost 30 years ago; High Definition Compatible Digital (HDCD), a 24-bit audio format, is 20 years old; and DTS (Digital Theater System), a format used in DVDs and other media, has provided 24-bit lossy audio for over 15 years.

Despite these decades-older technologies, the Zune HD device and marketplace doesn’t appear capable to deliver a better audio experience.

“By adding the “HD” to the name, [Microsoft] is trying to secure a market who appreciates the details, but that same market will likely reject the product if it doesn’t deliver a real HD experience beyond the “HD Radio”, which isn’t really HD at all,” said Hargett. HD Radio’s quality “is below what CDs, Apple Lossless, and FLAC downloads already deliver consumers for years. Does that really count as HD? I don’t think so,” Hargett quipped.

 
11 Comments


Read more: , , , ,

10 Comments For This Post

  1. nehalem Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 8:36 am

    here’s a quip for you – What exactly is “noted technology author” Matt Hargett noted for, besides “strategic planning for incremental rollout of agile practices”?

  2. David Worthington Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 11:08 am

    “Pragmatic Unit Testing in C# With Nunit” is another.

  3. JDoors Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 11:26 am

    How ’bout Microsoft slaps a sticker on the Zune saying, “HD Capable!”

  4. Matt Hargett Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 11:29 am

    Hi nehalem,

    I have also written several magazine articles; given talks/classes at conferences around the world; done hands-on HD recording, mixing, and mastering/encoding of music projects; and have a high-end sound system and HD audio collection that one of the top experts in the field helped me assemble.

    Not sure why it matters, though, since the facts are the facts and opinions are noted as such. I’d like Microsoft to succeed with this device to get some *real* competition in this space, but I’m just not seeing the innovation necessary to accomplish that.

  5. nehalem Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 12:39 pm

    Hey Matt, just having some fun with David’s characterization and this line of your bio, not questioning the validity of your opinions. The author must have felt you were qualified or he wouldn’t have quoted you.

    As I continue to relearn, sarcasm is lost on the net. /s doesn’t cut it.

    Be well.

  6. Crossi Says:
    June 20th, 2009 at 6:05 am

    Zune HD is amazing.

  7. Crossi Says:
    June 20th, 2009 at 6:09 am

    I like that gadgets with OLED screen.Picture is sharp,colors are natural.cannot wait to replace my old TV with some of that OLED TV. Check out http://www.oledgadgets.com.

  8. Aaron Says:
    July 18th, 2009 at 2:55 pm

    You do know that the “HD” in HD Radio does not stand for high-definition, right? It is just a marketing ploy to sell their “new and improved” radios. It’s simply the brand name of the technology that the company iBiquity created.

  9. Lester Says:
    August 16th, 2009 at 1:18 am

    go away ipod touch and come here Zune HD :)!!!

  10. Chickenman Says:
    May 4th, 2010 at 7:29 am

    When is HD not HD? When it is Microsoft HD.

    Marketroids say, “Hey, we don’t have to go through all the engineering bother and expense of making the Zune actually HD. We can fix it in marketing: we just have to slap ‘HD’ on the end of it, and presto-magico, it’s HD!”

    Marketroid lemmings all nod in agreement.

    And like a flying swimming pool, it’s real deep and goes over their heads.

1 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Fine HD » The Zune HD is Only HD to a Point | Technologizer Says:
    May 28th, 2009 at 4:48 pm

    […] example of that trend. The Zune HD looks like it will delivera compelling evolution … The Zune HD is Only HD to a Point | Technologizer VN:F [1.3.2_665]please wait…Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast) Leave a comment | Trackback […]